Most companies regret their first agency hire. These 7 questions reveal what case studies don't — and help you avoid signing with the wrong agency.
Most companies regret their first agency hire. Not because good agencies don't exist, but because the buying process is tilted toward the agency. They've done a hundred discovery calls. You've done two. They know exactly what to say to sound credible. You're evaluating something you can't fully assess until you're already six months into a contract.
These seven questions level the playing field. Ask them before you sign anything.
A great agency answers this specifically and in terms of metrics tied to your business: cost per lead, ROAS, pipeline generated, conversion rate improvement. A mediocre agency answers with brand awareness, content output, or follower growth — things that sound like progress but don't connect to revenue.
If the agency can't define 90-day success before you start, they won't be able to report it once you do.
Sales teams and delivery teams are two different groups at most agencies. The senior strategist who impressed you in the pitch may never touch your account after you sign. Ask directly: who will be our day-to-day contact? What is their background? Who do they report to? Can we meet them before we commit?
An agency that won't let you meet the team before signing has something to hide about the team.
Case studies are marketing. They're curated to show the best possible outcomes from the best possible engagements. What you need is a reference — a real person at a real company who will get on a call and tell you what working with this agency is actually like.
Ask for references from clients at a similar stage, budget, and industry to yours. If the agency's references are all enterprise companies and you're a growth-stage startup, their track record is essentially irrelevant to your situation.
This is the most revealing question on this list. Agencies that deflect, rationalize, or struggle to recall a failure are either not being honest or haven't pushed hard enough to ever fail. Both are problems.
A great agency will have a specific story: the hypothesis, the result that didn't match expectations, the pivot, and what they learned. That process — not a winning case study — is what you're actually buying.
There are two types of agencies: ones that optimize and ones that deflect. Optimizers look at underperforming campaigns, form hypotheses about why, run tests, and adjust. Deflectors blame the product, the market, the seasonality, the algorithm — anything except their own strategy or execution.
Ask this question and listen for specific language about testing, iteration, and learning. Vague language about "monitoring performance" and "making adjustments" is a deflector's answer.
This question reveals how self-sufficient the agency is versus how dependent they are on your team to do their job. Some agencies need significant client input: regular content approvals, access to internal data, creative direction. Others operate with high autonomy and minimal client involvement. Neither is inherently wrong, but there needs to be a match between what they need and what you can realistically provide.
If an agency promises to "handle everything" without asking what resources you have, they haven't actually thought through the engagement.
Confident agencies don't need 12-month lock-ins. A short initial term — 3 to 6 months — with a renewal option based on results is a sign that an agency believes in their own performance. Insistence on annual contracts with no performance clause is a sign they're more concerned with revenue predictability than client outcomes.
Read the exit clause carefully. Know what happens if you need to leave, what notice period is required, and whether there are penalties for early termination. An agency that makes leaving easy is one that plans to make staying worth it.
No agency can help you if you can't tell them what success means. Before you begin evaluating agencies, get specific about what you're trying to achieve: how much pipeline you need to generate, what your target cost per acquisition is, which channels you've already tested and what results you saw, and what marketing budget you can realistically sustain for 12 months.
Agencies tell you what you want to hear in sales conversations. The more specific your goals, the harder it is to give you a vague answer.
Beyond the seven questions above, watch for these signals during the sales process itself.
They talk almost entirely about their process rather than your outcomes. Process matters, but results matter more. An agency that leads every answer with "our methodology" rather than "here's what we achieved for a client in your situation" is optimizing for their pitch, not your business.
They can't give you a straight answer on pricing. Agencies that refuse to give even a range until they've done an extensive discovery are often fishing for a number to anchor against. A reputable agency has standard pricing that they'll share openly, even if the final number depends on scope.
The proposal arrives 48 hours after the first call. A proposal written that fast wasn't written for you — it was written for whoever they pitched last week with different names swapped in. Good proposals take time because they require understanding your business first.
Everyone you talk to is in sales or account management. If you can't get in front of the people who will actually do the work before you sign, there's a reason for that.
How We Work
